I watched the new Invisible Children video last night on my bus home from work. I haven’t watched an IC video since 2007ish when my friend forced me to do so. I have been familiar with the mission of IC, but for some reason it didn’t speak to me. I’ve never donated to them or bought a damn bracelet. But this time around, I had to find out what was making everyone repost it and retweet a 30-minute YouTube video. Suddenly everyone I knew was part of the crusade against Joseph Kony and the atrocities committed by his Lord’s Resistance Army.
What Joseph Kony and the LRA are doing is terrible, and I’m not trying to discount that. But I don’t think that Invisible Children or their crusade is worth my time or money. Their propaganda didn’t work on me in 2007, and it’s not working now. I take issue with a lot of what IC does, how they do what they do, and the fact that they’re more about quantity than quality when it comes to what they produce and propagate. My basic issues with IC are these:
This is a gross oversimplification of many issues. This type of reductionist thinking serves neither the people IC is trying to help, nor those providing that “help”. Clicking a link, bugging Angelina Jolie on Twitter, and emailing Condoleezza Rice doesn’t solve problems. Especially because, last time I checked, Angelina’s work as a UN Goodwill Ambassador isn’t influenced by what people tell her to do–only the UN does–and her primary work is with refugees. Condi–along with George W. Bush–isn’t currently holding political office. Reaching out to Bill Clinton doesn’t make sense either. (I know he got Lisa Ling’s sister out of North Korea, but his administration has a history of gains in peace talks and relations with NK).
Back in 2009, IC received the ire of Amanda and Kate over at WrongingRights because “organizations like Invisible Children not only take up resources that could be used to fund more intelligent advocacy, they take up rhetorical space that could be used to develop more intelligent advocacy.”
Click a link, share a video, PayPal five bucks is not how to encourage actual innovation and problem-solving.
They’re a Christian organization and they make no mention of that in their big huge video. Until this week, the only people I knew of that were IC supporters were Christians who heard about IC at church. I have no issue with Christianity in general. In fact, I am quite happy that one’s faith can motivate them to do good. But the idea of sending aid to people at their weakest makes them easy victims to proselytizers, and I don’t trust IC to maintain a secular environment or course of action. As victims of a crime, I think they deserve to have a fair and balanced start to recovery.
Invisible Children advocates for military action against Kony. Despite what the latest IC video leads one to believe, Obama allowing the US military to send its personnel to fight against Kony is not unprecedented, only the latest round in a series of efforts.
U.S. Africa Command (AFRICOM) has sent multiple missions to capture or kill Kony over the years. And they’ve failed time and time again, each provoking a ferocious response and increased retaliative slaughter. –Visible Children
I don’t support any military action of the United States in a country that is not a direct physical threat. Also, Kony’s soldiers are children and I cannot find what the Geneva Convention, International Criminal Court, or the United Nations has to say regarding protocol when dealing with child soldiers in direct combat. From what I can tell, they are in violation of the Law of Armed Combat and therefore can be captured, which would free them (in a way) but also make them POWs and that opens a whole new can of worms.
This whole idea that “we”–the average person with an internet connection–can and should stop Joseph Kony reeks heavily of neocolonialism and the idea of the white man’s burden. The political climate in Uganda–and everywhere else in Africa–is unlike any other in the world. This isn’t a situation where Kony is the only bad guy is running amok whilst everyone else is following the rules: Africa is full of shitty dictators and generals doing terrible things to people. The Ugandan Army itself isn’t exactly trustworthy either. This is, sadly, part of the political and cultural climate of the region. The concept of “peace” in many parts of Africa is relative; what it means you us in the western world is not the same as what it means to a person in Egypt or South Africa or Liberia. To interfere with that and pull one thread from the entire fabric may cause more to unravel than we are prepared to deal with. Which brings me to…
Invisible Children doesn’t really know what they’re doing. Let’s say Kony is caught and “brought to justice”–that always means a “fair” trial and execution, FYI. Assuming all the adults working under Kony are tried too, that leaves an army of brainwashed children. How many of them are mentally ill? How many suffering from Stockholm Syndrome? How many have embraced and become the culture of violence they’ve lived in for years? How are those people rehabilitated (as required by the UN!) and repatriated? I am ever the advocate for mental health, and I cannot think of any resource with as much manpower, money and ability as would be needed to help those kids.
Americans are dumb. Dumb enough put posters up that are just going to fall off and become litter? (Yes I am THAT granola now). Dumb enough to think Kony is running for office if they saw something like this, and quite possibly, write him in? You betcha!

In the Kony 2012 video, a young man says there are people involved from Canada and Mexico, and “every other state I can think of”… I don’t want to think that he doesn’t know Canada and Mexico are not states, but honestly I have no idea.
Stopping one person is a Bandaid on a bullet wound. Kony has been engaged in war efforts for over twenty years, so I’m sure he has his tactics down. Say he’s aware he’s about to be captured and sends one of his top guys into exile. After capture, new guy takes the reigns and the problem remains unsolved.
It has been said many times over that the best way to build up a culture is to support its medical and education infrastructures. A people, a country cannot exist or thrive without proper health care or an education. Educated people don’t believe everything they hear (like that having sex with a virgin will cure HIV/AIDS), or that a well-meaning campaign is telling the entire truth about a sensationalized topic. Healthy people have the energy to rebuild and make their own successes. Give your support to AMREF, Doctors Without Borders, or other organizations working to do concrete, tangible things for large groups rather than promoting a concept or a pipe dream.
Finally, I don’t trust an organization that’s willing to fly random bloggers across the world, or that handles criticism the way they are, and just seems unstable, self-serving, and sophomoric in every way. I don’t think it’s my job to play savior to anyone, and I am not alone.
I don’t think that the people who endeavor to support these issues are part of the problem; I just encourage them to research what they support before they go all in, or before they RT or Share.